In
2005, for managers other than the Chief Executive Officer,
40% of an employees long-term incentive compensation
opportunity was granted in the form of time based restricted
stock units. Restricted stock units represent shares of Verizon
stock that will become payable in cash approximately 3 years
after the date of grant. The value of each restricted stock
unit is equal to the fair market value of a share of Verizons
common stock on the date of grant and will change as the value
of Verizons common stock changes. This mix of equity
awards aligns with market practice and prevents unwanted dilution
through a more conservative approach to allocating shares.
Moreover, restricted stock units provide retentive value by
increasing stock ownership in the company through which the
value can be enhanced by superior share performance. This
further aligns the interests of senior management with the
long-term interests of the Companys shareholders.
The value of the performance stock units and restricted stock
units granted to each of the named executive officers is shown
in column (f) of the Summary Compensation Table.
Other Benefits. Verizon also provides its executives
with the other benefits that are described below and that
are intended to be part of a competitive overall compensation
program.
Company Transportation. The Committee requires Messrs.
Seidenberg, Babbio and Strigl to use aircraft maintained by
Verizon for business use as well as personal travel, for security
purposes. The Committee believes that this also enables more
efficient use of their travel time. Mr. Barr and Ms. Toben
are permitted to use the corporate aircraft for personal use
on a limited basis. Verizon also provides a driver and Company
owned car to Mr. Seidenberg and certain other named executive
officers are permitted to use a driver and Company owned car
for limited personal use, primarily involving commuting to
work and traveling to and from business meetings. Information
concerning the incremental costs for the use of Company provided
transportation by Mr. Seidenberg and the other named executive
officers is set forth in the Summary Compensation Table and
related notes beginning on page 30.
Company Housing. Based on a past agreement, Mr. Babbio
had periodic use of a Company owned apartment during 2005
for business and personal reasons. Neither Mr. Babbio nor
any other named executive officer will have use of a Company
owned apartment in 2006. Information concerning the incremental
costs for the use of this Company owned apartment is set forth
in the Summary Compensation Table and related notes beginning
on page 30.
Executive Life Insurance. Verizon currently provides
executive life insurance policies to its senior management
employees, including the named executive officers, on a voluntary
basis. These policies are designed to provide a death benefit
equal to five times an executives eligible compensation
if such executive were to die while an active Verizon employee.
If an executive continues the policy after retiring from Verizon,
the death benefit is reduced to two times an executives
eligible compensation. The policies are owned entirely by
the Verizon executive and Verizon pays each executive a bonus
to cover the partial cost of maintaining such policy. All
senior management employees, including the named executive
officers, are excluded from participation in Verizons
basic and supplemental life insurance programs if they choose
to participate in the executive life insurance program. The
amount of each bonus paid to the named executive officers
to cover the partial cost of the executive life insurance
plan is set forth in the Summary Compensation Table and related
notes beginning on page 30.
Financial Planning. Verizon provides financial planning
benefits to the entire senior management group, including
the named executive officers. Part of the cost associated
with the financial planning services used by each executive
is imputed to such executive as ordinary income for the year
in which the cost was incurred. The amount of the cost of
the financial planning services paid to each of the named
executive officers is set forth in the Summary Compensation
Table and related notes beginning on page 30.
SUMMARY OF EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION CHANGES FOR 2006
As previously reported, the Committee approved freezing the
accrual of future benefits under the Verizon Income Deferral
Plan and eliminated the 32% retirement contribution credit
on eligible compensation, as of the close of business on December
31, 2004. Only senior managers were eligible to participate
in this plan. Beginning on January 1, 2005, executive officers
and other senior managers began receiving the same benefits
as described below as other employees under the Verizon Excess
Pension Plan (VEPP). More specifically, the executive officers
and other senior managers became eligible to receive retirement
pay credits equal to 4%-7% (depending on age and service)
under the VEPP, on all eligible compensation that exceeds
the IRS qualified pay limits ($210,000 in 2005). This is the
same pay-credit percentage range received by all other management
employees who participate in the VEPP. This action reduced
the future pension credits received by Verizon executive officers
and other senior managers from 32% to a range of 4%-7%.
At the end of 2005, the Company announced the restructuring
of retirement benefits for all management employees. This
change does not impact current retirees. The restructuring
is designed to align retirement benefits for management employees
and to provide Verizon with a more affordable benefit cost
structure so that it can more effectively compete with companies
that do not provide defined benefit pension plans or subsidized
retiree medical benefits. In implementing this change the
Company announced that it will provide employees with an enhanced
savings plan opportunity that is more in line with current
trends and will allow employees to have greater responsibility
in managing their own finances.
Accordingly, effective July 1, 2006, all Verizon management
employees will no longer earn pension benefits under the Verizon
Management Pension Plan and the VEPP. For management employees
earning pension benefits as of June 30, 2006, the Company
will fully vest their pension benefit and will enhance the
pension benefit earned as of that date by adding 18 months
of additional cash balance pay credits to pension accounts
and, if applicable, 18 months of service to the highest average
pay formula pension calculation. Management employees hired
after January 2006 are not eligible for pension benefits under
the Verizon Management Pension Plan or the VEPP. In addition,
Verizon management employees who have at least 15 years of
service (including the additional 18 months) or who are age
65 with at least 5 years of service (including the additional
18 months) as of June 30, 2006, and who become eligible for
company subsidized retiree medical coverage (without taking
the additional 18 months of service credit into account),
will have their company subsidy toward retiree medical benefits
calculated based on service through June 30, 2006 plus an
additional 18 months. Verizon management employees will not
earn service toward the company retiree medical subsidy after
June 30, 2006. Verizon management employees who do not have
15 years of service with the additional 18 months of service
added as of June 30, 2006 will not have any company subsidy
for retiree healthcare or life insurance. However, these Verizon
management employees will be able to purchase retiree healthcare
and life insurance through Verizon at their own expense once
they are retirement eligible.
Beginning July 1, 2006, the Company will provide management
employees with an enhanced savings opportunity under the qualified
savings plan. Verizon will provide a matching contribution
equal to 100% of the first 6% of eligible compensation deferred
or contributed to the savings plan. In addition, in order
to shift to an even greater performance driven benefits and
compensation structure, management employees will be eligible
for an additional performance related matching contribution
of up to 3% of eligible compensation if the Company meets
certain performance criteria.
For management employees whose eligible compensation exceeds
the IRS compensation limits, Verizon will provide the same
matching contributions on eligible compensation exceeding
the IRS compensation limits under a nonqualified savings plan.
2005 COMPENSATION FOR THE CHAIRMAN AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
The Committee meets each year in executive session with the
other independent Directors to evaluate
the performance of Ivan Seidenberg as Chairman and Chief Executive
Officer of Verizon. The results
of the evaluation are considered in determining his compensation,
consistent with the compensation
policies described above. The Committee also consults with
the HRC Consultant in setting
Mr. Seidenbergs compensation. The level of Mr. Seidenbergs
2005 compensation was determined in
accordance with the policies and practices discussed in this
report.
In January 2005, the independent members of the Board of
Directors approved a change in the structure of Mr. Seidenbergs
compensation, after considering the increasing competition
in the telecommunications industry, Verizons comprehensive
business strategy, and shareholder interests in Verizons
continued success. The independent members of the Board approved
the first increase in five years to Mr. Seidenbergs
salary, reflecting the Companys success in creating
growth and building market share in a highly competitive environment
and to align his base salary to the base salary level of his
market peers. Mr. Seidenbergs salary increased $600,000,
from $1,500,000 to $2,100,000. His 2005 salary was determined
based on his individual performance in 2004, changes in the
market value of comparable positions since 2000, and the economic
and business conditions affecting Verizon. His 2005 base salary
is in alignment with the base salary levels of other chief
executive officers at other large global public companies
comparable to Verizon. His annual salary is shown in column
(c) of the Summary Compensation Table, and his short-term
incentive award is shown under Bonus in column
(d) of this table.
In 2005, under Mr. Seidenbergs leadership, the Company
delivered strong financial and operational
performance as the Company continued to grow its customer
base through innovative products in
wireless, broadband, data, video, and long-distance services.
In addition, Verizon continued to make
significant investments in updating its network and infrastructure
in order to effectively compete for
customers in the fast paced telecommunications environment.
The Company continues to
demonstrate its ability to grow and build market share in
a highly competitive industry. Verizons
annual consolidated operating revenues increased 6.0%, driven
by 16.8% revenue growth at Verizon
Wireless and by 10.5% revenue growth in wireline data revenues.
Also, in 2005, Verizon announced
the proposed acquisition of MCI, a transaction that will strengthen
the Company and enhance its
ability to more fully serve the growing large business, government
and enterprise customer groups.
For 2005, Mr. Seidenberg was eligible for a maximum short-term
incentive award equal to 2.5 times his annual base salary.
He received an award of $4,147,500 based on the factors discussed
above. In 2005, Verizon continued to introduce innovations
in wireless, broadband, data, video and long-distance services
resulting in strong growth. Verizons total customer
connections, which include wireline switched access lines,
wireless customers, and wireline and wireless customers using
broadband connections (EV-DO, DSL or FiOS) increased 5.7 percent
to 105.3 million at the end of 2005. Verizon generated $22.0
billion in cash from operations, an increase of $192 million
from 2004. Total debt was reduced by $300 million to $39.0
billion.
Mr. Seidenbergs 2005 long-term incentive award
was structured to align his total compensation opportunity
with his industry peers and to place more of his total compensation
at risk. Accordingly, in February 2005, Mr. Seidenberg
received an award consisting of 314,480 performance stock
units and 209,660 restricted stock units. During 2005, Mr.
Seidenberg periodically reviewed with the Board the Corporations
strategies for investment of capital to transform the company
and the launch of Verizon Business following the closing of
the MCI transaction, all of which are designed to create sustainable
long term shareholder value. In recognition of the ongoing
transformation of the Companys business, Mr. Seidenberg
and the Committee, in consultation with the HRC Consultant,
reviewed the current market conditions and discussed the competitive
assessment of the amount and terms of Mr. Seidenbergs
long-term incentive award. Mr. Seidenberg and the Committee
agreed to restructure Mr. Seidenbergs 2005 long-term
incentive award by aligning the entire value of his 2005 award
to performance stock units. As a result, on March 3, 2006,
Mr. Seidenbergs February 2005 RSU award was canceled
and his 2005 long-term incentive opportunity consists of 314,480
performance stock units at their original February 2005 grant
value of $11.34 million. The 2005 PSU grant dollar value is
reported in column (f) of the Summary Compensation Table.
This award represents Mr. Seidenbergs target opportunity
and will be based on the measures described on page 25. The
actual payment will be determined by the Companys relative
performance over the performance cycle as previously described
and shown in the table above. No performance stock units will
be paid to Mr. Seidenberg unless Verizons relative TSR
position meets a specific minimum threshold percentage at
the conclusion of the award cycle. The value of Mr. Seidenbergs
award may increase or decrease based on Verizons relative
TSR position compared to that of the Standard & Poors
500 companies and the companies in Verizons industry
peer group as previously described. The value of each performance
stock unit is equal to the fair market value of a share of
Verizons common stock on the date of the grant and will
change as the value of Verizons common stock changes
over the award cycle.
In addition, the Committee restructured the grant to add certain
strategic objectives related to the
successful launch of Verizon Business, the new enterprise
business created from the acquisition of
MCI and the overall competitive financial and operational
positioning of Verizon. To the extent that
synergy targets relating to the launch of Verizon Business,
key legislative initiatives, FiOS and
broadband initiatives, and Wireless growth objectives are
met or exceeded for the applicable
performance period, the Committee may modify Mr. Seidenbergs
2005 PSU payout level, but in no
event shall Mr. Seidenbergs 2005 PSU payout level
exceed two times his target award value of
$11.34 million. Conversely, Mr. Seidenberg will not be eligible
for an award if minimum TSR targets
are not achieved for the applicable performance period.
Mr. Seidenberg no longer accrues any benefits under the Verizon
Income Deferral Plan (IDP). As
discussed above, effective December 31, 2004, the Committee
froze the IDP for all participants and
ceased any additional benefit accruals under the IDP. Before
2005, the IDP provided Mr. Seidenberg a
guaranteed annual supplemental retirement credit in an amount
equal to 32% of his eligible pay. This
retirement credit was replaced by a nonqualified pension plan
that provides pension credits that range
from 4%-7% on compensation that exceeds the IRS compensation
limits. This is the same pay-credit
percentage range received by all other management employees
who participate in the Verizon
Management Pension Plan and the nonqualified pension plan.
Please see the discussion above and
below for the 2006 changes to the pension benefits for Mr.
Seidenberg and the other named
executive officers.
STOCK OWNERSHIP GUIDELINES
The Companys stock ownership guidelines reinforce each
executives position as an owner of the business. The
guidelines require each executive to maintain a significant
ownership stake in the Company. The ownership levels are based
on base salary and require a multiple of at least five times
base salary for the CEO and a multiple of at least four times
for the other named executive officers. These guidelines apply
to all senior management employees. All named executive officers
are currently in compliance with the stock ownership guidelines.
The table on page 36 shows the current ownership levels of
these named executive officers.
APPLICABLE TAX CODE PROVISION
Under the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993, provisions
were added to the Internal Revenue Code under Section 162(m)
that limits the tax deduction for compensation in excess of
one million dollars paid to certain executive officers. Companies
are not permitted to deduct that portion of an executive officers
salary in excess of one million dollars but are permitted
to exclude performance-based compensation from the limit if
that compensation meets certain requirements. The Committee
believes that the shareholder approved short- and long-term
incentive plans provide for appropriate performance driven
factors and therefore satisfy the requirements for exemption
under Internal Revenue Code Section 162(m). However, under
certain circumstances, the Committee exercises its discretion
to make certain grants and awards that may not comply with
the terms and conditions under Section 162(m) of the Internal
Revenue Code in order to maintain the Committees flexibility
to grant awards that will continue to attract, retain and
properly motivate qualified executives. Accordingly, the Committee
has from time to time approved elements of compensation for
the named executive officers that are not fully deductible,
when appropriate.
Respectfully submitted,
- Human Resources Committee
-
- Walter V. Shipley, Chairperson
- Richard L. Carrión
- Robert W. Lane
- John R. Stafford
Dated: March 3, 2006
|